Debt consolidation, is it a good idea? All you need to know.

 


Debt Consolidation, is it worth it?  What are the pitfalls?  Is it too good to be true?

This subject comes up time and time again.  People ask me "Should I put all my debts into one simple payment" 

Banks and Finance Companies rely on the fact that, if they make things simple, it doesn't matter how much it costs.

There are a number of things to consider:

  • what are the debts you are wanting to consolidate?
  • why are you wanting to consolidate?
  • will it mean you are paying less?
  • will it help you get ahead?
When we look at the first question, think about what debts you have and ask yourself:  Are you paying interest on them now?  Are they growing?  If the answer is no to either of those questions then you shouldn't get a debt consolidation loan to pay them.  You will be more in debt than you are now.

If you are being charged interest on an existing debt, eg. car loan, personal loan, store card, that means most of the interest is paid at the beginning of the term, you would have already paid a lot of interest on the debt, now, by consolidating it into one loan you are starting from scratch and paying interest all over again on the same debt.

When looking at what debts you are wanting to consolidate, be careful about consolidating normal monthly bills, if you get behind with them, make an arrangement with the company you owe money to and pay it off a little at a time, and they will not charge you interest.

If you are wanting to pay off student loans, fines, IRD or WINZ loans, don't stress about paying them off early, if your payments are too high, make an arrangement to adjust them to levels that are appropriate.  These have no interest added to them and if you add them to a debt consolidation they will have heaps added to them and you will pay more, so your debt will increase.

Debt consolidation loans work on the principle that you pay less each week/month than you are paying now, however they also work on the principle that you will pay substantially more than you pay now to pay the same debt.  I have an example below to show you what I mean.

A debt consolidation loan will increase the debt you owe by a substantial amount, I have used them myself before and it has taken forever to get out of the situation they have put me in.  Here is an example using a typical debt consolidation loan scenario.

Current debts

Personal loan      $10,000    Repayments $233/month            term 5 yrs                        total $13,980
Student loan        $25,000    Repayments $125.41/fortnight    term 7yrs 10 mths          total  $25,000  
Power arrears        $1,000    Payments $100/fortnight             term 10 fortnights           total $1000
Internet arrears      $1,000    Payments $100/fortnight            terms 10 fortnights            total $1000
total debt             $37,000    total payments  $937/month                                                total $40,980

Debt consolidation

total debt $37,000  Repayments $937/month                         term 7 yrs                        total $78,602

This is based on a debt consolidation interest rate of 19.99% but many are way higher than that.

As you can see, by paying the same amount the loan term increases and the total to pay is over double the original debt.  It is imperative that you make arrangements with the people you owe money to and make it affordable for you rather than going down this path.

I hope this helps you, please feel free to follow, share, like and comment my blog.  


Comments

  1. Keith3 August 2023 at 11:53

    Brilliant as always. Love the example of loans and repayments.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous4 August 2023 at 05:06

    The difference is actually quite shocking.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Granny Sarah's most popular Solutions

The concept of contents insurance. Replacement of things from insurance. How much to insure things for?

Image
It is interesting when we get insurance, any form of insurance, we are advised by the person who is selling it to us.  Let's think about that for a moment......... Lots of things in life are like that, salespeople are supposedly the experts in their field.   In the 70s my dad was a mechanic, he also sold cars, the cars he serviced, so he was the expert, he knew about cars intimately!  Still does!  Things have changed dramatically, we now have specialist car sales people, that's all they do, they know a minimal amount about the actual mechanics of the vehicle and their only job is to sell it to you.   Insurance sales people are the same as that.  At the end of the day, their job is to sell a product that "suits" you.  They are in the business of selling and that is how they earn their keep, we have to respect them for that.   I was sold very high contents insurance,  I had it for many years.  I did a lot of research in this space and I guess the thing is, we are paying
Read more

Am I losing money on my Kiwisaver? Is it a good investment? What is really happening? How can I find out what my real return is when comparing it to other investments?

Image
  Is Kiwisaver "worth it"?  One of the most common questions I get asked.   The simple answer is absolutely!! My Kiwisaver figures are above, the one on the left is the amount I have contributed, the top line is what I have personally put into it.  The numbers on the right are what my Kiwisaver balance is today. I have been in Kiwisaver since day one so a long time now, but the deductions from my salary over the years has been $42,603, my Kiwisaver net balance is $114,368. Basically, the return is ridiculously high, I challenge anyone to get a this type of return on investment anywhere.  When people say, "I have lost $5,000 on my Kiwisaver, it is ripping me off"  I challenge them to look at these two screenshots for themselves. The one on the left is from the Inland Revenue Department and anyone can get it in about five minutes by logging in, or longer if you have to call them, unfortunately the wait time can be horrendous.  I feel for the people that work there act
Read more

The joy of interacting with people "in person" is it overrated? What happens when we bump into someone face to face? Should we talk to strangers?

Image
  The importance of physical interaction with people, family, friends, strangers, just people as opposed to online!! Due to COVID and all sorts of other events, like cyclones and difficulties getting around on our roads, there have been a lot of cancellations and times where we haven't been able to interact with those we love.  Communities have been missing out on vital physical social interaction.  Sure, everyone is on social media and in contact through their phones and the internet, but not in the same room. It has been a tough last week in my local community.  I have had people in tears in my classes, over a very special young person taken way too soon.   As a community we gave him the most beautiful, sad, incredible send off, his friends and family were amazing.  Of a town of around 4000 people there were about 2000 people in attendance.  What a beautiful community, we needed to get together to grieve.  It made me think of the importance of support in a purely physical way tha
Read more