Is it worth borrowing to invest? Should you invest when you still have debt? Are you making emotional financial decisions?


Have you been told to borrow to invest?  Do  you have any idea of what that looks like?  I want you to have a good zoom in and look at the above two graphs, this is an actual situation someone was in.

This person, let's call him Bob, has a $25,000 investment, fixed term cash account.  Great!  We are all envious of him.  

Bob also has a $25,000 credit card that is maxed out, so -$25,000, he is paying $500 per month on that card.

I went online and found the above calculators, the credit card on is at www.sorted.org.nz  and the other is at www.calculator.net  both of these are reliable and you can pretty much punch in any numbers you want to check out your own debt and investment.  

This is a really important exercise to do at any time to see how you are tracking on your goals.

The comparison for these two appears like this:
  1. Investment of $25,000, in this incident I was looking at paying $500/month, into this account, (same as credit card monthly payment) to see how much could be gained.   Over five years, the amount of interest gained would be $1207.99
  2. Credit Card of -$25,000, in this situation, once again I looked at paying $500/month, into this account to see what it would cost Bob, the amount of interest charged over five years, would be $19,444
So when people suggest paying the credit card off with the money saved or invested, they often say, no way, as they want a nest egg.

But they will continue to drip feed the credit card, remember the credit card, compounding interest will always be greater than any interest offered on any fixed deposit account.

In this case the difference over five years is astronomical the gain being $19,444 less $1207, so a gain (or negative loss) of $18,237.

The best investment is to manage and pay off your debts.  Don't increase your debt at great expense in order to have a tiny payment of interest (that is taxed).

I hope this helps you, there is a lot of "interesting" advice out there.  Be careful.  Feel free to share, comment, like, or follow this blog.  I am an independent Financial Adviser and an independent Financial Advice Provider fully registered, so I  have no vested interest in which way you go on your journey. 
 

Comments

  1. Keith21 June 2023 at 17:36

    Great stuff Sarah! .. A nice simple, but powerful (and life changing) financial exercise for anyone to follow and implement .. Well done!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Granny Sarah's most popular Solutions

The concept of contents insurance. Replacement of things from insurance. How much to insure things for?

Image
It is interesting when we get insurance, any form of insurance, we are advised by the person who is selling it to us.  Let's think about that for a moment......... Lots of things in life are like that, salespeople are supposedly the experts in their field.   In the 70s my dad was a mechanic, he also sold cars, the cars he serviced, so he was the expert, he knew about cars intimately!  Still does!  Things have changed dramatically, we now have specialist car sales people, that's all they do, they know a minimal amount about the actual mechanics of the vehicle and their only job is to sell it to you.   Insurance sales people are the same as that.  At the end of the day, their job is to sell a product that "suits" you.  They are in the business of selling and that is how they earn their keep, we have to respect them for that.   I was sold very high contents insurance,  I had it for many years.  I did a lot of research in this space and I guess the thing is, we are paying
Read more

Am I losing money on my Kiwisaver? Is it a good investment? What is really happening? How can I find out what my real return is when comparing it to other investments?

Image
  Is Kiwisaver "worth it"?  One of the most common questions I get asked.   The simple answer is absolutely!! My Kiwisaver figures are above, the one on the left is the amount I have contributed, the top line is what I have personally put into it.  The numbers on the right are what my Kiwisaver balance is today. I have been in Kiwisaver since day one so a long time now, but the deductions from my salary over the years has been $42,603, my Kiwisaver net balance is $114,368. Basically, the return is ridiculously high, I challenge anyone to get a this type of return on investment anywhere.  When people say, "I have lost $5,000 on my Kiwisaver, it is ripping me off"  I challenge them to look at these two screenshots for themselves. The one on the left is from the Inland Revenue Department and anyone can get it in about five minutes by logging in, or longer if you have to call them, unfortunately the wait time can be horrendous.  I feel for the people that work there act
Read more

The joy of interacting with people "in person" is it overrated? What happens when we bump into someone face to face? Should we talk to strangers?

Image
  The importance of physical interaction with people, family, friends, strangers, just people as opposed to online!! Due to COVID and all sorts of other events, like cyclones and difficulties getting around on our roads, there have been a lot of cancellations and times where we haven't been able to interact with those we love.  Communities have been missing out on vital physical social interaction.  Sure, everyone is on social media and in contact through their phones and the internet, but not in the same room. It has been a tough last week in my local community.  I have had people in tears in my classes, over a very special young person taken way too soon.   As a community we gave him the most beautiful, sad, incredible send off, his friends and family were amazing.  Of a town of around 4000 people there were about 2000 people in attendance.  What a beautiful community, we needed to get together to grieve.  It made me think of the importance of support in a purely physical way tha
Read more